Metal Lair Complaint Department: Google Search Is Broken

Written By Remmy Chillmister

METAL LAIR COMPLAINT DEPARTMENT COMPLAINT NO. 003: GOOGLE, YOUR SEARCH RESULTS ARE FULL OF EMPTY CALORIES

Google search is burying the independent web. They don’t have a content problem, they have an authority addiction.

Big publisher ranks, gets discovered, gets backlinks, gains authority, ranks again.

Small publisher doesn’t rank, isn’t discovered, doesn’t receive backlinks, lacks authority, doesn’t rank.

That’s a goddamn moat. And then Google tells the people outside the castle to write better.

The problem isn’t just that the results are bad. It’s that they’re boringly optimized. You search for something genuinely interesting about metal and get twenty variations of:

“10 HEAVIEST BANDS OF ALL TIME ”

Metallica. Slayer. Pantera. Slipknot. Iron Maiden.

Groundbreaking archaeological discovery there, lads. Someone alert the Smithsonian.

Meanwhile, buried six pages deep is some obsessive bastard who spent four nights researching the Colombian death-metal tape-trading scene in 1991, interviewed two people who were actually there, translated an old zine, tracked down a vanished demo and wrote 4,000 words that make you understand something you didn’t know existed.

And Google goes:

Hmm. Only twelve backlinks. Into the cellar with you.

The internet was supposed to make publishing more democratic. Instead, search increasingly feels like a shopping mall where the anchor stores get the entrances and everyone interesting is selling records out of a basement three blocks away.

And the ugliest part: SEO sludge masquerading as editorial. Not every listicle is garbage. We make lists too. But there’s a difference between:

“Here are 60 underground labels, what they actually do, where they’re based, what they release and how bands can submit.”

…and:

“15 METAL BANDS YOU NEED TO HEAR BEFORE YOU DIE”

followed by fifteen gigantic bands selected because those names have search volume. That isn’t discovery. That’s keyword farming wearing a battle vest.

And then the system compounds itself. Publishers chase what Google already rewards, so everybody writes about the same six bands, the same anniversaries, the same five “best albums,” the same recycled trivia.

Google sees mountains of engagement and links around those subjects, decides that must be what people want, and rewards more of it. A giant feedback loop eating its own tail.

Google helped turn online discovery into an aristocracy, and the result is a web full of safe, repetitive, search-engine-approved empty calories while genuinely interesting independent journalism survives underground.

WELCOME TO THE GREAT CONTENT FOOD COURT

Because that’s what page one can feel like now. McMetallica. Burger Maiden. Taco Slayer.

Meanwhile the strange little restaurant around the corner is cooking something fucking incredible and nobody can find the door.

The modern search ecosystem can create a self-reinforcing caste system where sites that already possess authority, links, money, scale and name recognition keep accumulating more visibility, while smaller publishers are told to simply “make better content.”

Google itself confirms that PageRank and link analysis remain part of its core ranking systems, even though backlinks are only one signal among many. It also says its systems use site-wide signals and classifiers in addition to page-level assessments.

March 2026 Chartbeat data covering thousands of publishers found that sites with 1,000 to 10,000 daily pageviews lost 60% of search referral traffic over two years, while publishers above 100,000 daily pageviews lost 22%. That does not prove Google deliberately suppresses small publishers, but it absolutely gives us grounds to ask why the smallest publishers are being hit almost three times as hard.

Then there’s HouseFresh, an independent publisher that actually buys and tests the products it reviews. It reported dropping from roughly 4,000 Google visitors a day to about 200 after algorithm changes, while generic recommendations from much larger media brands remained prominent. Their subsequent analysis of independent publishers found similarly brutal declines, though that research is their own dataset and should be presented as such, not gospel.

Google says its systems are designed to elevate original, helpful, reliable content.

Meanwhile, independent publishers are screaming:

“WE MADE THE FUCKING ORIGINAL HELPFUL CONTENT. YOU BURIED IT.”

A writer can spend six hours researching an underground band, interview the musicians, understand the history, hear the record, contextualize the genre, edit the piece and publish something nobody else on Earth has written.

Then some enormous entertainment site can publish:

BAND ANNOUNCES NEW ALBUM

Band X has announced a new album.
It arrives November 7.
Check out the single below.

…and Google goes:

BEHOLD. AUTHORITY

AUTHORITY IS NOT THE SAME THING AS EXPERTISE

And that is where this whole thing becomes ridiculous.

A backlink can tell Google that somebody referenced a website. It cannot tell Google whether the writer spent twenty years immersed in death metal, actually interviewed the band, knows the difference between first-wave black metal and the Norwegian scene that followed, or can spot recycled press-release bullshit before finishing the first paragraph.

Authority signals measure things. They do not magically measure knowledge.

A huge publication can have an enormous backlink profile and still publish three paragraphs of reheated PR copy.

A tiny independent site can have almost no institutional clout and publish the definitive interview, history, review or investigative piece on a subject.

Yet one walks into Google wearing a VIP laminate. The other gets asked for identification. That is the absurdity at the center of modern search.

THE INTERNET IS GETTING SMALLER WHILE PRETENDING TO BE INFINITE

There are millions of websites out there. Thousands of writers. Magazines. Metal blogs. Podcasts. Zines. Independent journalists. People obsessed enough with one microscopic corner of music to know things the giant publications never will.

But if search keeps handing visibility to the same handful of enormous domains, does any of that abundance matter if nobody can find it?

Discovery used to mean falling through a trapdoor.

You searched for one band, found some lunatic’s blog about another band, discovered a label in Finland, ended up listening to a demo recorded in somebody’s freezing garage in 1994 and somehow lost three hours of your life.

That was the good shit. Now we get recommendation loops polished until every sharp edge is gone.

The same names, same stories, same “essential” albums. The same bands you already knew before you fucking searched.

At some point, a search engine that continually tells us what is already popular stops being very good at helping us discover anything.

WE ARE NOT ASKING FOR CHARITY

Independent publishers do not deserve rankings merely because they are independent.

Bad writing is bad writing whether it comes from a multinational media company or Dave’s Death Metal Dungeon dot net.

Rank the work, reward originality, reward firsthand reporting, reward expertise. Reward somebody who actually interviewed the artist over somebody who rewrote the press release announcing the interview somebody else did.

And maybe stop treating popularity as evidence that something deserves more popularity.

Because when the same institutions already holding the microphone keep getting handed another microphone, eventually the room stops sounding diverse.

It just gets louder. So congratulations, Google. You built a machine capable of indexing almost the entire human internet…

…and somehow searching it can still feel like eating at the same six restaurants.

Complaint filed.

Now somebody please tell us where the weird little place around the corner went.

We’re fucking starving.

– Remmy Chillmister
The Metal Lair Complaint Department

That’s how you know it’s real. Yinyo.

Missed last week’s Metal Lair Complaint Department? Find it here.

The Metal Lair Complaint Department artwork featuring an overflowing complaint box on a rusted filing cabinet with drawers in an office setting

The Metal Lair Complaint Department® is a Metal Lair Original Series.

SUBMITTED COMPLAINTS

Name: [REDACTED]
Complaint: “Dear [REDACTED],

Thanks for ignoring every email I’ve sent you for the last six months.

Very elite. Very exclusive. Very ‘you may approach the velvet rope but you may not enter.’

I hope your inbox develops sentience and starts marking you as spam.

Warm regards,
Someone You Definitely Never Replied To

P.S. “You bitch!”

Remmy responds:

Ah yes. The ancient PR ritual known as “pretend the email never arrived.”

Look, nobody owes anybody an interview, a premiere, a guest list spot, or even a yes.

But if someone sends a professional request and follows up once, replying with “not available” takes roughly twelve seconds.

Silence, meanwhile, has somehow become a personality type. So no, you’re not entitled to access. But basic courtesy is still free.

So no, you’re not entitled to access. But basic courtesy is still free. Apparently nobody told [REDACTED].

Name: Gatekeeper With Standards
Complaint: “Dear Remmy,

Can you please stop using the word ‘underground’ for bands that have 80,000 monthly listeners?

That is not underground. That is a functioning municipality.

If a band has a publicist, a booking agent, three vinyl variants, a European tour, and a professionally filmed music video, I should not have to pretend I discovered them in a sewer tunnel.

Some of us are trying to find bands with 214 listeners and a logo that looks like it was carved into a tree with a spoon.

Please recalibrate.

Remmy responds:

Fair.

“Underground” has become one of those words everybody keeps using until it means absolutely fucking nothing.

A band does not become mainstream because somebody outside their hometown knows who they are, but there is a difference between genuinely obscure and “not Metallica.”

Maybe we need a new scale:

0–500 listeners: underground
500–5,000: emerging
5,000–50,000: people are clearly finding you
50,000+: stop pretending you were discovered in a crypt

Complaint accepted.

Now go support somebody whose merch is still being mailed from their drummer’s kitchen table.

Name: SkibidiSabbath
Complaint: “Dear Remmy,

Why are you always complaining about everything?

You sound like a miserable boomer yelling at Spotify.

Maybe the problem isn’t modern music, social media, algorithms, PR people, ticket prices, streaming, AI, festivals, journalism, or literally everything else. You’re just old.

Respectfully,
Someone born after your favorite album came out.”

Remmy responds:

First of all, fuck you.

Second, “an angry boomer yelling at Spotify” is probably the most accurate description of my career anyone has ever written.

Third, being younger does not automatically make you correct. It just means your knees still work and you voluntarily film yourself lip syncing to my favorite album.

I survived dial-up internet, CD wallets, MySpace autoplay, and metalcore haircuts. You will not defeat me with age jokes.

Now get off my algorithm.

FILE A COMPLAINT WITH THE METAL LAIR COMPLAINT DEPARTMENT

Have a metal-related grievance that needs official investigation?

Bad concert etiquette? Venue bullshit? Festival fuckery? A trend in metal that needs to die? An industry annoyance? Something that’s been pissing you off since 1987? Have a complaint against Metal Lair?

FILE YOUR COMPLAINT

File it with the Complaint Department. Remmy may investigate your grievance in a future installment.

Selected grievances may be investigated, mocked, dissected or otherwise subjected to the questionable judgment of Remmy Chillmister in a future edition of The Metal Lair Complaint Department.

Submission does not guarantee investigation. Remmy has a substantial backlog of things that piss him off.

About The Author

Remmy Chillmister survives on beer, bad decisions, and one functioning ear since ’79. Banned from three metal festivals, countless venues, and one nursing home for excessive honesty. Nobody knows why he still has a press credential, including him.

The Metal Lair Complaint Department

AUTHORITY IS NOT THE SAME THING AS EXPERTISE

THE INTERNET IS GETTING SMALLER WHILE PRETENDING TO BE INFINITE

WE ARE NOT ASKING FOR CHARITY

FILE A COMPLAINT WITH THE METAL LAIR COMPLAINT DEPARTMENT

FILE YOUR COMPLAINT

About The Author

Read more from this author:

UNLEASH YOUR METALHEAD HOROSCOPE: ZODIAC FATE WEEK OF SEPTEMBER

WORLD METAL WEEKLY MEXICO